Insider’s Take on the MS-01 Childers/Davis Race

What can we take from the victory of Democrat Travis Childers over Republican Greg Davis in Mississippi’s 1st Congressional District? Is it a bellwether for Democratic success in the fall? What is to be learned especially as we look ahead to Alabama’s House races this fall?

A Mississippi Republican offers Parlor readers an insider’s perspective on the Childers-Davis race:

Mississippi's 1st Congressional District in the northern part of the stateLooking back on this special election, I’m reminded of what Ole Miss coach Johnny Vaught frequently said: You don’t win games on the field. You win them on recruiting day.

When Greg Davis won the nomination to run for this seat in November, Mississippi Republicans lost the seat. The same campaign philosophy that made him the nominee (a very DeSoto County-centric, scorched earth strategy against Tupelo’s Glenn McCullough) ensured that the special election would be a fight between DeSoto County and the rest of the district… and guaranteed a loss. As has been said in the press over the last couple of days, it enabled Travis Childers run on a populist platform, break away (at least publicly) from his own national party, and frame this as a regional battle. Brilliant strategy on their part – the DCCC should be commended. If Anzalone had a hand in that, he certainly deserves to be on the list of winners.

The Republican nominee was stiff and not at all personable, and by all accounts, had high unfavorables by the time he reached the special election run-off. Compounding that, the prototypical conservative v. liberal message was entirely misguided. The good news for Republicans is that the message was unified, which is obviously much better than having a potpourri of messages coming from various organizations. The NRCC, the Davis campaign, the state party, even Freedom’s Watch- they were all nailing Childers to Obama. The bad news is that message was wrong. This year, simply connecting a candidate to Obama won’t work, even in districts where the white population makes up the overwhelming majority. Folks in AL-5 and AL-2 would do well to pay attention to the lesson Mississippi Republicans just learned the hard way.

Tom Cole held a conference call Wednesday with reporters, and said that after three special election losses in a row, it becomes less an issue of campaign tactics and more an issue of the product we’re putting in front of voters. Following that logic, Karl Rove wrote in Thursday’s WSJ that the first two losses were a result of “bad candidates” and the third a result of the Democrats nominating a conservative. Rove is partly right – the third loss, too, is a result of a bad candidate.

It’s easy for the Montgomery politico to comment on the Parlor Thursday that the NRCC should have done “whatever it took.” That politico should understand that you can spend a million, spend two million, spend whatever you’ve got – but if all things are equal with the candidates on election day, the jackass that can’t relate to the rural, hardworking Mississippian (or Alabamian) is the one that’s going to lose, even if he is a Republican.


Related Articles:

8 comments to Insider’s Take on the MS-01 Childers/Davis Race

  • Political Groupie

    I agree. Greg Davis is an idiot. He was the absolutely worst candidate to get elected in the general. Either Glenn McCollough or Dr. Randy Russell would be a Congressman if they would have won the nomination.

  • Tobie

    I think that people are finding out that white people are not as racist as these Republican pundits want to make them out to be. I think the attaching a candidate to Obama is looked at very differently than attaching them to Kerry. People see this as some sort of racial statement and not a political or party statement which in turn causes the exact opposite reaction in the voters.

  • It's Always the Candidate

    Remember when Joe Turnham thought he would be a Congressman? Same thing with that little kid with no job who’s running against Mike Rogers this year — I’ll re-quote Coach Vaught “You win on recruiting day.”

  • dot

    Rogers ??
    –pffffffffft–with that cheesy toupee he can do infomercials for Latham’s hair replacement after he gets bounced from Congress

  • Blame it on the candidate. Nice GOP spin!

  • walt moffett

    Think the best takeaway quote is “the jackass that can’t relate to the rural, hardworking Mississippian (or Alabamian) is the one that’s going to lose …”

  • related

    The It’s Always the Candidate philosophy might not help with Mike Rogers.

    He’s very lucky that he’s never drawn a top notch opponent, being no gem himself.

  • related

    Also, why not blame the pollster who said that Obama’s minister was the most potent negative on Childers. Or blame the ad guy who ignored his pollster if that’s the case.

Legislative Dispatch

A Look from the Rearview Mirror

This Thursday will mark the last day of the legislative Session.  For some, it was a Session that seemed would never end.  For others, it was one that ended much too quickly.  It may be early, yet, to write an obit on this Session, but as we approach the finish line, some perspective may be in order.

[...]

Putting Students First

As you know, a very important piece of legislation will be presented for our consideration in the House tomorrow in Montgomery – Senate Bill 310 – the “Students First” tenure and fair dismissal reform bill. Like me, many House members have been inundated with phone calls and emails from opponents of this bill, and some have been [...]

Legislative Transparency

There are a lot of issues to debate before we begin the final days of this session. In fact, I am quite certain there will be some comments on this post debating many of them. Before we get into the last seven day of the session I wanted to bring up a topic that [...]


See more Recent Small Town News