Ranking the State House Races

Thanks to political insiders on both sides of the aisle who have helped us reconsider the ratings on the state House races.

I’d like to expand on this a bit later, but for now let us simply get right to it with little comment.

Here is how the ratings have changed.

HD 1 from Toss Up to Lean Dem – Greg Burdine (D) v. Quinton Hanson (R) for the seat vacated by Tammy Irons (D)

HD 2 from Toss Up to Lean GOP – incumbent Mike Curtis (D) v. Lynn Greer (R)

HD 5 from Lean GOP to Likely GOP – incumbent Henry White (D) v. Dan Williams (R) with Independent Jerry Hill in the race also.

HD 7 from Likely Dem to Lean Dem – incumbent Jody Letson (D) v. Ken Johnson (R)

HD 8 from Toss Up to Lean GOP – Drama Breland (D) v. Terri Collins (R) for the seat vacated by Bill Dukes (D)

HD 9 from Lean GOP to Likely GOP – Kathy White Goodwin (D) v. Ed Henry (R) for the seat held by Ron Grantland (D)

HD 12 from Lean Dem to Toss Up – incumbent James Fields (D) v. Mac Buttram (R)

HD 13 from Likely Dem to Toss Up – incumbent Tommy Sherer (D) v. Bill Roberts (R)

HD 14 from Toss Up to Lean GOP – incumbent Ken Guin (D) v. Richard Baughn (R)

HD 16 from Likely Dem to Lean Dem – incumbent William Thigpen (D) v. Daniel Boman (R)

HD 21 from Lean Dem to Toss Up – incumbent Randy Hinshaw (D) v. Jim Patterson (R)

HD 22 from Lean Dem to Toss Up – incumbent Butch Taylor (D) v. Wayne Johnson (R)

HD 24 from Likely GOP to Lean GOP – Nathaniel Ledbetter (D) v. incumbent Todd Greeson (R)

HD 27 from Lean Dem to Toss Up – incumbent Jeff McLaughlin (D) v. Wes Long (R)

HD 29 from Likely Dem to Lean Dem – incumbent Jack Page (D) v. Becky Nordgren (R)

HD 35 from Lean Dem to Toss Up – incumbent Steve Hurst (D) v. Steven Dean (R)

HD 37 from Likely Dem to Lean Dem – incumbent Richard Laird (D) v. Bob Fincher (R)

HD 39 from Likely Dem to Lean Dem – incumbent Richard Lindsey (D) v. Timothy Sprayberry (R)

HD 42 from Lean Dem to Lean GOP – incumbent Jimmy Martin (D) v. Kurt Wallace (R)

HD 61 from Likely Dem to Lean Dem – incumbent Alan Harper (D) v. Frank Chandler (R)

HD 62 from Likely GOP to Safe GOP – John Merrill (R) v. Constitution Party candidate Steven Kneussle. Dem candidate dropped out.

HD 63 from Lean GOP to Likely GOP – Susan Pace Hamill (D) v. Bill Poole (R) for the seat vacated by GOP gubernatorial candidate Robert Bentley.

HD 73 from Lean GOP to Toss Up – Joe Hubbard (D) v. incumbent David Grimes (R)

HD 80 from Safe Dem to Lean Dem – incumbent Lesley Vance (D) v. Mervin Dudley (R)

HD 81 from Lean Dem to Lean GOP – incumbent Betty Carol Graham (D) v. Mark Tuggle (R)

HD 84 from Safe Dem to Likely Dem – Berry Forte (D) v. Joyce Perrin (R) for the seat vacated by Billy Beasley (D)

HD 86 from Lean GOP to Toss Up – Merritt Carothers (D) v. Paul Lee (R) for the seat vacated by Benjamin Lewis (R)

HD 90 from Likely Dem to Lean Dem – incumbent Charles Newton (D) v. Jerry Hartin (R)

HD 91 from Toss Up to Lean GOP – incumbent Terry Spicer (D) v. Barry Moore (R)

HD 92 from Lean GOP to Likely GOP – David Darby (D) v. Mike Jones (R) for the seat opened by the retirement of Seth Hammett (D)

HD 93 from Likely GOP to Safe GOP – Ronnie Helms (D) v. incumbent Steve Clouse (R)

With 105 seats in the House, 53 is a majority. If you look at the whole list and tally them up, you see 53 in the red (lean, likely or safe GOP), 43 in the blue (lean, likely, or safe Democrat), and 9 toss ups. There will be some surprises, but with this as our starting point there will have to be a lot of surprises in the Dems’ favor or we are looking at a GOP majority in the state House.

Related Articles:

Benjamin Lewis in as Judge, Out of HD 86

First term state Rep. Benjamin Lewis (R – Dothan) is giving up his place on the ballot in HD 86. He has been appointed as Houston County District Judge by Gov. Bob Riley. Some smell politics behind the appointment.

Lewis figured heavily in the story of the electronic bingo bill that passed the Senate. Had it passed the House, the bill would have brought the gambling issue to a vote of the people in a statewide referendum. The Country Crossing entertainment complex, in Lewis’ district, strongly supported the bill.

The Dothan Eagle this week:

The bill never came to a vote in the Legislature, but Lewis said repeatedly that he did not like the bill. A Country Crossing lobbyist said Lewis was the reason for the bill’s downfall in the House, because his lack of support for the bill gave other representatives cover to vote against it.

In the same article, Gov. Riley is quoted, “Ben is the most qualified candidate for this important position and I am proud to appoint him” while Merritt Carothers, the Democratic nominee in HD 86, believes the appointment was a reward from Riley for standing by the Governor on the electronic gambling issue.

“This is a prime example of cronyism,” said Merritt Carothers, the Democrat nominee for the House District 86 race. “I feel it is disrespectful to all of the qualified attorneys in town who have applied for the job and been overlooked in place of someone who is, with all respect, wet behind the ears.”

Other Democrats tell the Political Parlor that HD 86 has looked like a potential pickup opportunity for them, and that the appointment allows the Republicans to pick a stronger candidate than the incumbent who angered some of the home crowd with his opposition to the bill.

One consideration that fuels the argument that Lewis’ appointment as District Judge is political: Lewis was appointed to replace District Judge John Steensland not even two months after Steensland retired. Yet in Autauga County, a District Judgeship has remained open since the end of December because of money woes that led Chief Justice Sue Bell Cobb to ask Riley to leave the position open. Todd Stacy, the Governor’s press secretary, told the Montgomery Advertiser in April that the Autauga County position would remain open indefinitely. (Google cache of the story is here for now.)

This seat was a pickup for the Republicans in 2006 when Lewis defeated long term state Rep. Joe Carothers, the father of this year’s Democratic nominee. (FWIW, I’m reminded by this old post that BCA supported Lewis with more money than any other legislative candidate including Speaker Seth Hammett and House Minority Leader Mike Hubbard. Aside from those two, BCA gave to Lewis approximately three times as much money, $57,500, as they did to any other legislative candidate.)

The Dothan Eagle reports that the Houston County Republican Executive Committee had until yesterday to submit nominations to replace Lewis. At that time, Committee Chair Charlene Erbskorn had received five names.

Erbskorn declined to release those names, but three have confirmed they have been asked and are interested in running. Dothan City Commissioner Paul Lee, Dothan Planning Commission Chairman Chuck Harris and outgoing Houston County Commissioner Bobby Snellgrove all said Thursday they are open to running, but they want to see the process play out before they discuss it publicly.

The Houston County Republican Executive Committee will submit its top three choices to the steering committee of the State Republican Executive Committee who will ultimately select the new nominee.

Legislative Dispatch

A Look from the Rearview Mirror

This Thursday will mark the last day of the legislative Session.  For some, it was a Session that seemed would never end.  For others, it was one that ended much too quickly.  It may be early, yet, to write an obit on this Session, but as we approach the finish line, some perspective may be in order.

[...]

Putting Students First

As you know, a very important piece of legislation will be presented for our consideration in the House tomorrow in Montgomery – Senate Bill 310 – the “Students First” tenure and fair dismissal reform bill. Like me, many House members have been inundated with phone calls and emails from opponents of this bill, and some have been [...]

Legislative Transparency

There are a lot of issues to debate before we begin the final days of this session. In fact, I am quite certain there will be some comments on this post debating many of them. Before we get into the last seven day of the session I wanted to bring up a topic that [...]


See more Recent Small Town News